The Importance of Dice

Dice are a very important part of most role playing games. Without out a good set of dice you would not be able to roll up your character, let alone slay a dragon. They are just as important to people who play roll playing games as the story they are playing through. Some people take this very seriously. I remember reading a story some time back about a player who buried his dice in the back yard after a bad roll that resulted in the death of his character. Yet others are more than willing to share their game dice with a new player. It all depends on the person.

As important as dice are to players, the way they roll their dice is just as important.  Some people give them a quick shake in the hand and let them fly. Others will spin their dice  high into the air and let them drop down right in front of them. Yet, others will blow on their dice casino style before they roll. Each person is hopping that these little rituals they do with their game dice will improve the out come of what they roll. You can witness this first hand by watching Chris Perkins and the writers from robot chicken playing Dungeons & Dragons. Each person (most of which are new to roll playing and have never touched a d20 before) has their own roll style.

When I was looking at getting into Dungeons & Dragons last year I started by picking up the Dungeons & Dragons Foruth Edition RPG Starter Set. When I got home and opened the box one of the first things that poured out into my hands was my first set of dice. Up till this moment I had never owned my own set of dice. With the six multi-colored dice in my hand my mind exploded with possibilities of the other kinds of cool dice I could get. I think I spent hours that first night searching the internet for dice. That should show you how important dice are to me.

After looking though all the Steel, Bone, Hematite, Opaque, Translucent, Glitter, Speckled dice the internet had to offer I settled on a set of Green opaque dice with white numbers. Green being my favorite color and opaque making it easy to read the white numbers. Sometimes settling on the simplicity of just being able to read quickly what you have rolled is more important and time-saving then getting a crazy translucent yellow dice with elvish print that takes you way to long to read after it’s stopped rolling. That’s just my preference. Everyone has their own and that is what makes this topic so fascinating to me.

Recently my views on dice all came crashing to the ground thanks to a company called Game Science. One of the things Game Science states about their own dice is:

“My company makes polyhedral dice closer to casino specifications” (casino dice must be exact to a tolerance of .005″ – Gamescience dice have been measured with a side to side variation of .002″ to .006″)

So with a sharp edge on the Game Science Dice, your roll is truly random since their are no curvature variations. The sharp edges also allow for better stopping power.
Now, is all this true? I honestly don’t know. I think casino’s have have sharp edge dice for a reason and I think that holds some weight. Game Science has two videos on their website with the owner talking about his dice and why they are better then all other roll playing dice on the market. After watching the videos the guy lays down a pretty convincing argument. But he is such a good salesmen I also think he could sell sand to a guy living in the desert.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bR2fxoNHIuU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PxmkWrDbn34

After watching these videos it’s hard for me to know if one brand of dice is truly better then any other brand on the market. I just don’t have enough validated facts to say one way or the other. As important as dice are to me and to roll playing games in general the biggest reason I play D&D is to have time set aside in my week to meet up with my friends and socialize. I don’t need casino grade dice to do that.

With all that said I drank the Kool-Aid and  ordered a set of Lime Green Game Science dice.

You know…

So I can review them…

17 comments

comments user
Stargazer

While I can understand why some players prefer the GameScience dice, I am a great fan of Q-Workshop dice. They may not produce 100% random results, but they are so pretty! My favorite dice are currently the green glow-in-the dark Cthulhu dice. 🙂

comments user
Siskoid

Yes, dice are important to gamers, for sentimental reasons as much as anything. But they’re also necessary! There is a psychological effect that dice have that… wait, I know I’ve said something about this somewhere… Hold on a sec… Ok, yes, here’s my take on it.

The Crash of the Dice

Sorry to cross-polinate like that, but it was either that or cut and paste into your comments.
.-= Siskoid´s last blog ..Previews for RPGs (No, Not the Catalog) =-.

comments user
Lugh

I drank the Gamescience kool-aid after listening to him talk at Gen Con one year. I bought two d20s, and used them religiously. For about three months. I don't know why, but I found them much less satisfying. It's like the clinical precision killed all the spirit in the dice. Also, they were kinda hard to read.

My favorite company is Crystal Caste. They have a lot of nifty dice.
.-= Lugh´s last blog ..How fragile we are =-.

comments user
Zachary Houghton

Man, I love Gamescience dice. Picking out some at their booth at Gen Con and getting to talk to Lou Zocchi is worth the price of admission.

Q-Workshop dice are beautiful, but sometimes I have trouble reading the numbers on some of their more ornate sets.
.-= Zachary Houghton´s last blog ..Enter Traveller =-.

comments user
Rob Lang

I use a metal set of silver dice. Nothing says "UP YOURS" like the clunk of metal dice.
.-= Rob Lang´s last blog ..My die is bigger than your die in Adventure Squad by Andrew Domino =-.

comments user
Lugh

I use this one:

http://crystalcaste.com/mm5/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=CC&Product_Code=02018&Category_Code=DM

Well, until the other players asked me to stop, because it would shake the table when I rolled it…
.-= Lugh´s last blog ..How fragile we are =-.

comments user
Siskoid

Hahaha, that's brilliant Rob! Intimidate the bastards.

I use a black die that keeps being referred to as the death die. Not quite as kickass, but has the desired effect.
.-= Siskoid´s last blog ..Previews for RPGs (No, Not the Catalog) =-.

comments user
Stargazer

And don't forget Abraham's unusual dice! I can't wait to use the three gears' dice he gave to me! 🙂

comments user
DNAphil

I also got GameScience dice at this past GenCon. I love them. They roll great, and while they are not as pretty as my vast Chessex collection, I do feel that they are rolling a lot more random then some of my past dice.

comments user
Youseph

@Zachary, I hope I enjoy my Gamescience dice as much as you enjoy yours. Just waiting for them to show up in the mail.

@DNAphil, Glad to hear it. I feel that as a Dungeon Master I should be doing all I can myself to keep the game random.
.-= Youseph´s last blog ..Writing For Stargazer’s World =-.

comments user
Moriarty

Well, science or no science, sharp-edged dice are definitely attractive, so there's always that advantage at least.

comments user
Alex Schroeder

I don't need truly random dice. It's good enough if we think they're random. Also, there are ways to test wether your dice are random or not!

http://deltasdnd.blogspot.com/2009/02/testing-bal
.-= Alex Schroeder´s last blog ..Spielertyp =-.

comments user
Youseph

@Alex, Great link. Thanks for sharing.

Also, like I tried to state in the post, it’s the socializing that keeps me coming back to D&D. Not how anal I can be about the rules or the dice. Good times with good friends.
.-= Youseph´s last blog ..Writing For Stargazer’s World =-.

comments user
RTM

Good Old Lou Zocchi! I've actually spoken to Lou on numerous occasions over the phone, and he really does beleive in his product. And the science backs him up on this, there is indeed a good reason not to polish your dice. 🙂

comments user
Canageek

I have a complete set of the original expert box sets dice. I don't use them, but still.

I like sharp edged dice because they stop rolling faster.

Use metal dice on my oak table and I will beat you to death with them.

I have two sets of Gamescience dice but I have yet to use them in a game. I would say the main problem I have with them is the bits you have to sand off: I think that having to sand off that is going to cause more randomness problems then the side length.
.-= Canageek´s last blog ..A History of Below =-.