I still maintain that "piracy" is the new "terrorism". You can justify any action so long as you say you're doing it to fight "pirates".

I would not mind them having a steam like app through which you can buy and view their role playing manuals. It will allow the online books to get automatically updated as changes in rules occur. The could even add a code in their hardcover books for us to activate on this app and then get the online one as well.

All the points you make are valid to the point of obviousness. Yes these old out of print books could be a source for much needed revenue, yes when consumers are given the choice between a (free) low quality scan and a well made (reasonably priced) digital copy, they will tend to choose the latter. The policies put in place by WOTC regarding this don't seem to make sense because, well they don't make sense. This is a company that has grown larger than it's market. Every year new independent developers pop up from all over to take a nibble out of the big guy's food source and so the portions keep diminishing. So what do they do? They hunker down and hope brand recognition and market saturation will lead them through. "Innovative" ideas are unwelcome in this mindset, no matter how much sense they make.

Actual, modern-day pirates that take people hostage are definitely in bed with terrorists. People illegally downloading copyrighted material are merely thieves. WotC still has a right to do what they can to protect their copyright and Hasbro has their eye on the bottom-line. Most of the people in the OSR won’t buy material from WotC anyway, even if they started producing legacy product in support of older editions of the game. Legacy PDFs would be fantastic, but from what I can tell, the D&D team at WotC is stretched pretty thin as it is. Their current online product, the character builder, is unimpressive at best, and I don’t have high hopes for the forthcoming Monster Builder. I haven’t seen the online virtual table top yet.

I would love to see legacy PDFs up on the WotC site as part of the DDI subscription, though. That would definitely boost the value of my subscription in an instant.

There's two reasons why I think Wizards decided to pull their PDFs. The first reason was because the old product was competing with a then-fledgling 4e line. The second was because PDF sales were also likely seen as competing with the print sales of 4e, which could result in book stores returning unsold product, and costing Wizards / Hasbro some cash. I believe the piracy argument was concocted as an excuse to pull the PDFs from the market to try and save face on both fronts. Ultimately, though, it's not a sustainable strategy, since print sales are already flagging, and PDFs are a great alternative in tough economic times for those gamers who are a little strapped for cash.

You shouldn't want those old things. They're badwrongfun. Stop liking the old stuff better than the new! What's wrong with you???

Harumph!

-The Gneech
My recent post It’s Been … Unexpected- The Eyre Affair by Jasper Fforde Review

They pulled the pdfs because they were being pirated, it is as simple as that. People like to read more into to such things, such as WotC trying to "keep down the little guy" or "its all part of some master plan to bone the consumer" etc, but the fact is they lost a lot of money to piracy when 4E launched and thereafter. If you followed some of the court cases after the fact they lost over $500,000 from the piracy. I will contend that while piracy still continues it does so less, at the very least it has become harder for piracy. WotC no longer spends resources providing the pdfs for the pirates to use.
Should they release some legacy stuff on pdf? Yes, it would be a fast way to generate cash without a lot of production cost. I suspect they are going to do something of the sort within the next year, but other than intuition I have no facts to back that up.
As for Alternity, I do not believe it was ever a pdf. Therefore they would have to assign production money to making it a pdf. Would they get their investment back? Maybe. Would they get their investment back and on top of that the money they could have made using those resources to produce something new? That I doubt.

Well, since they are phasing out print books anyway, I think we'll see a return of the pdfs eventually. All that needs to happen is for the D&D team to realize that I'm not choosing between a 4e product and the Moldvay books. Sell me the Creature Catalog or forgo my $$. They will begin offering the pdfs again when they realize they need to increase revenue and the pdfs are already ready to go. (Actually, I'd be even more interested in a PoD release I could order thru Lulu or whatever.)

It seems more and more artists believe that this thing we call Piracy is just people lending books. Case in point: http://www.yousephtanha.com/blog/2011/02/16/neil-…

Unfortunately it seems that both Metallica and Wizards of the Coast don't see it that way.
My recent post St Patrick’s Day Gig

With the new OBS POD option and the option to get PDF + Print through them, WoTC really should put the out of print stuff up. I don't buy the downloading hurts sales argument, but fine don't put your current stock online, but there is no argument for not putting out of print items up as you aren't selling them so there are only two options: file sharing or used books. With POD and PDF no books should ever be out of print.

I really still don't get their policy here. Take me for example. I'am a computer person – I work at the PC, play, read etc. I don't want to buy paper books at all. I don't buy fiction or any manuals this way. I have my laptop and e-book reader, thank you very much. Besides I have to pay some 30 dollars to have physical books delivered to me. So yes I pay for DDi sub and, I admit, download pirated pdfs. So I mostly play WotC stuff, but my money goes to small indie publishers, which do sell pdfs.
Fighting piracy? WotC, that's called encouraging it in my book.
In short – give me back the way to take my money to you, WotC.

Look at Pinnacle. Savage Worlds comes in PDF format, and snatched that up as a seperate purchase when I ordered the latest version of SWEX at their store because it was easy and affordable and I know I'd get the latest edition for my tablet. I'm an adult, and don't have the time or the patience or the lack of moral fiber to screw around with bit torrents of RPGs. The way I see it, if you make it easier than free to get your products, then you will find your profit. Ignore the kids looking for torrents, they were never your market in the first place.

Also I love @Telur 's idea of a "Steam for PDF's" service — but for God's sake, it shouldn't be offered with heavy handed DRM or in a proprietary format or device. Again, charge me for it, but make it open, easy to get, and easy to transport, and easy use – (password protected PDF is the answer there). The company that figures that out will rule the RPG publishing industry of the future.

Wizards are using the mentality of not selling knives in case someone stabs someone. It's flawed logic and you're absolutely right.
My recent post Creating a great Tunnels and Trolls monster